This "Commodity" Supplement has a $268 Cart Value (no VSL)

You can buy magnesium on Amazon for $9 a bottle:

So how do you turn a $9 commodity supplement like this into a premium purchase that generates a $268 cart value...

…in just 57 seconds?

Today in this newsletter we’re breaking down a fascinating YouTube Shorts ad that does exactly that.

(And we break down the full funnel that turns this into a $268 cart value, inside the Funnel of the Week Members Area)

But to understand why it works (and how to apply this to your own offers), we need to first understand what legendary copywriter Eugene Schwartz called "Market Sophistication."

Schwartz argued that every market goes through 5 distinct stages of sophistication. 

And when you know which stage your market is in, you know exactly how to position your offer.

Let's look at the magnesium supplement market:

Stage 1: "Magnesium helps you sleep!" (Basic claim, new market)

Stage 2: "Magnesium helps you sleep BETTER!" (Enlarged claim)

Stage 3: "Magnesium helps you sleep better because of [mechanism]" (Mechanism becomes key)

Stage 4: "Our unique form of magnesium..." (Complex mechanism differentiators)

Stage 5: "For people who want the best sleep possible..." (Identification/aspiration)

The magnesium market is firmly in Stages 3-4.

This means:

• Everyone knows the basic benefits

• Simple claims no longer work

• Price compression is brutal ($9 bottles everywhere)

• Big brands dominate shelf space

• Scientific claims are commonplace

This creates what you might call the "commodity trap" - where your product is seen as interchangeable with every other option, forcing you to compete on price alone.

Most supplement companies try to escape this trap by:

1. Making bigger claims (which triggers skepticism)

2. Cutting prices further (death spiral)

3. Adding more ingredients (complexity)

4. Pushing scientific studies (questionable)

But this 57-second YouTube Shorts ad takes a completely different approach.

It uses what Schwartz called a "new mechanism" - a fresh way to make old promises believable again.

Let's break down exactly how they do it...

The 57-Second “New Mechanism” (YouTube Shorts Ad Breakdown)

Now that we understand the market challenge, let's break down how this ad navigates it. Pay close attention to the strategic sequencing - every second is purposeful.

[0:00 - 0:03] Pattern Interruption Opening + “Borrowed Credibility”

The ad opens with a brilliant contrast play: positioning a New York Times "Ask Well" article questioning magnesium's efficacy against their own "Truth About Magnesium & Sleep" statement:

“If you're having trouble sleeping, you gotta stop sleeping on magnesium.”

This creates immediate tension and authority - what Gary Bencivenga calls "borrowed credibility."

[0:03 - 0:15] Benefit Stack & Market Position 

Next section:

“I'm Daniel, the founder of Organics Ocean. And magnesium is a mineral that can help with not only sleep, but stress and muscle cramping. And magnesium glycinate is the preferred magnesium due to its incredible absorption rate.”

Instead of just shouting "better sleep!" like every other magnesium supplement, here’s what this ad does:

• Lead with the sleep benefit (primary market desire)

• Stack additional benefits (stress, muscle cramps)

• Introduce the mechanism (magnesium glycinate)

• Use scientific terminology while keeping it accessible via visual explanations:

Key Point: Notice how they're not trying to educate the market about magnesium's benefits. They assume (correctly) that the market already knows them. This is crucial in Stage 3-4 markets.

[0:15 - 0:25] The Competitive Destruction Phase

This section is masterful. Here is the copy + some key visual frames:

“Now, not all magnesium glycinate is made equally. So stay away from magnesium sourced from China and the big brands over the counter. Also stay away from oxide, magnesium oxide blends.”

Instead of just claiming superiority, they:

• Name specific types to avoid (Chinese sources, oxide blends)

• Attack both low-end AND premium competitors

• Maintain educational tone while destroying alternatives

• Signal insider knowledge through specific terminology

Why this works: In sophisticated markets, prospects are skeptical of "better than" claims. But specific, educational warnings about what to avoid? That's valuable information.

[0:25 - 0:32] The New Mechanism Introduction 

Here's where they introduce what Schwartz calls the "new mechanism" - their unique solution:

• Dead Sea sourcing (exotic authority)

• "46 times less heavy metals" (specific claim)

• Unique form (Chelamax magnesium glycinate)

Key visual frames really help illustrate why the Dead Sea sourcing is special specifically:

Copy here:

“The only magnesium you want is Chelamax magnesium glycinate. Source straight from the Dead Sea because it has 46 times less heavy metals than others.”

Notice that hyper-specific "46 times" claim. Not 45, not 50. Forty-six. This level of precision suggests real testing and data, not marketing puffery.

[0:32 - 0:57] Close & Bridge

The final sequence follows classic direct response architecture:

1. Restate core promise

2. Simple usage instruction

3. Risk reversal (90-day guarantee)

4. Value-add option (bulk pricing)

5. Soft CTA (call-to-action)

But this 57-second YouTube Short ad is just the beginning...

What happens next is even more fascinating:

A sophisticated funnel that turns this premium positioning into a $268 cart value - without using a traditional VSL (Video Sales Letter).

What’s inside the funnel?

Inside the Funnel of the Week Members Area, we went through and bought the full funnel (and all the upsells) to show you exactly how it works:

You’ll discover:

• The complete funnel architecture that builds on this video's foundation

• How each page reinforces and amplifies the premium positioning

• The psychology behind their bulk offer strategy

• The complementary offers they choose to enhance AOV

• Their risk-reversal approach that makes premium pricing feel safe

• The specific page elements that maintain premium positioning while driving urgency

Want the complete breakdown?

Go here to check out the funnel breakdown inside the Funnel of the Week Members Area.

Have a great week!

The Funnel of the Week Team

PS - in case you’re wondering, what Funnel of the Week is all about…

More on What’s Inside Funnel of the Week Members Area

Funnel of the Week has been live just one month now, and if you haven’t logged in for a bit, here’s what you’ve been missing:

We continue to stack full funnel breakdowns each and every week inside the Members Area:

We’ve got: 

• ecomm funnels

• VSL funnels

• Info Products funnels

• (and more)

…And we add a new funnel breakdown & swipes each week.

So if you have a funnel you want us to break down?

(Including all the landing pages, order bumps, upsells, downsells, email/sms followup & more…)

Just let us know and we’ll add it to our Funnel of the Week “next up” list. 

We’ll go through the funnel, document all the funnel steps, email/sms followups, etc. as we become a real customer (we don’t ask for refunds), and document the whole process so you have it at your fingertips.

If you’re not yet inside the Members Area? Go here to learn more about Funnel of the Week & get access.

The big idea of Funnel of the Week is this:

We break down a new DTC funnel (including ads, front end offer, upsells, post-purchase emails/sms/etc.), each and every week.

Here’s a quick Google doc walking through what we at Funnel of the Week has got in store for you, each and every week:

Check it out. We’re doing a special “early bird” price for access for a limited time.

And if you want great funnel insights delivered to your email inbox, multiple times per week? Go here to sign up for our Funnel of the Week email newsletter (it’s free) funneloftheweek.com

That’s all for today.

Have a great week!

The Funnel of the Week Team

PS: Not yet subscribed to our free Funnel of the Week newsletter? Join now for exclusive insights: https://funneloftheweek.com

PPS: What insights do YOU want in our funnel breakdowns? Hit reply and share your thoughts

PPPS: Got a funnel you think we should break down? We’d love to hear your suggestions!